I’ve posted this on the Warrior’s Forum and I thought I wanted to put the same review here. I didn’t want give too much review on Magic Article Submitter as it seems like the directories are not updated so that’s a big disappointment for me. Perhaps in the near future they will update their software and I hope to look at theirs again.

Article Demon (AD)
Pros

• Clean user interface, the calendar scheduling is very neat
• More comprehensive reporting
• Able to setup pen names (Important to Article Dashboard)
• More accurate category targeting (Lesser chance of submitting to wrong category)
• Auto-creation of accounts
• Allows reposting on failed directories

Cons

• On average, I can submit to only 250-300+ directories
• Quite a bit of preparation is needed before you can finally submit (like selecting exact categories for EACH directory)
• Article Demon seems to run a queue which takes up quite a bit of time
• Submission seems to be slower

Article Marketing Robot (AMR)
Pros

• On average, I can submit to 800-900+ directories
• Faster, simpler setup before I can submit
• Cheaper by $50
• Submission seems to be faster
• Auto-creation of accounts
• Shows how good are the directories with “Health Status”

Cons

• Looks like every button is on the same screen, a little confusing at first
• No proxy setting
• Only one decapcher service available
• No pen names setup
• May have higher chance of sending to wrong category IF you define less than 6 catergories
• It will create a cache HTML file for every submission you make. It can clutter the hard disk

Conclusion
AD has a more consumer-friendly software but it really lacking in the number of directories it has. If it has over 1,000 article directories I would really think it is a winner. Perhaps AD is still new, which is why they don’t have a lot of directories but I will definitely keep a look-out on new development of AD.

AMR is obviously a software developed by a hard-core developer, which explains why it doesn’t have a friendly interface. The submission is faster and it is has a lot of directories submitted. It’s strange why AD does not have proxy servers as some of the users will have higher chance of not able to submit due to IP blocking.

If I am one who believes in submitting to as many directories as possible, AMR would be my choice. If you are one who wants better management of the submission, AD would be your choice. And, AMR runs faster than AD.

So, which one will you choose? You decide.